the importance muslims attached to the qur'an
As we have pointed out above, the verses and chapters of the Qur'an
were in oral use amongst Muslims at the time of its first and second compilation
into one volume. They were extremely careful in preserving what they had
learnt by heart.
Moreover, a large group of companions and their followers were engaged
only in recitation and learning the Qur'an by heart. The collecting together
of the Qur'an into one volume took place under their scrutiny. They all
accepted, without objection, the volume when it was given to them and then
made copies of it.
It happened that when some men tried to record verse 34 in "Repentance,"
"And those who hoard up gold and silver" without the "and" in the 'Uthmanic
(second compilation) volume, they were prevented from doing so. The companion
Ubayy ibn Ka'b swore that if anyone left out the "and" he would fight him
with the sword.
As a result, the word "And" was recorded. One day the second Caliph,
during the time of his own caliphate, read the verse, And the first
to lead the way of the Muhajirin and Ansar and those who follow them in
goodness. [IX:100], without the word "and"; he was opposed and
forced in the end to read it with the "and".
The Qur'an that had been compiled by 'Ali was rejected by several people
when he showed it to them. Despite this, Ali made no objection or resistance
and accepted the Qur'an in circulation for as long as he lived, even during
the time of his own caliphate.
Likewise, the Imams of the Prophet's family, the successors and sons
of the Prophet, did not mention their objection to the Qur'an to the intimates
amongst their Shiah followers. They always referred to the Qur'an in common
use and in their commentaries and ordered the followers to recite it as
the people did.
Ali's silence in the matter of the difference of order between the two
volumes was in keeping with the preference of the Shiah Imams for commentary
of the Qur'an by the Qur'an; for them the order of the Medinan and Meccan
chapters has no influence on the meanings of the Qur'an; commentary of
each verse is made by comparing it to another group of verses.
Moreover the Qur'an is eternal and valid for all times and places; such
local and temporary particularities as this time, place and circumstances
of revelation can have no effect on the higher scale of meanings contained
in the qur'an.
It is true that there are benefits to be gained by knowing certain details
of revelation; they help one to discern the development of divine wisdom,
social laws or stories of the past prophets and nations; also an understanding
of the reasons for revelation show how the call to Islam progressed during
the twenty-three years of the prophet's mission.
We would like to make clear, however, that it was in order to preserve
the unity of the Muslims that caused the Shi'ites to be silent in this
matter.