The Validity of the Commentary of the Prophet and the
imams
From an indication in the Qur'an itself, the commentary of the Prophet
and the Imams, (as discussed in the previous sections), is established
as being absolutely true. Authentication of the sayings of the Prophet
and the Imams is clearly established by the existence of fully trustworthy
chains of transmissions. A tradition may not, however, be recognized as
totally acceptable if it has been transmitted by one chain of narration
only.
The validity of the tradition may be disputed amongst the Muslim Scholars
of Commentary: amongst the Sunni's a tradition of a single chain of transmission,
classified in their terms as sahih (sound), must be accepted and acted
upon; among the Shi'ite scholars a tradition with a single undisputed chain
of transmission is also accepted as a proof.
However, in the laws of the shari'ah it is not valid and must be investigated
and checked before use as a proof.
Author's Note: The previous section has been specifically about the
use of commentary or explanation in order to arrive at the true meaning
of a verse. This includes study of the literal meanings and those hidden
in metaphor. It does not include an explanation or a discussion of the
linguistic and literal aspects or the science of Qur'an recitation since
these do not affect the meaning.